Respect above all
The following images originate from a liveaboard expedition to the Farasan Banks, Saudi Arabia, in 2023. During that week, in which I was unfortunately participating as an individual and not in a group leadership capacity, I witnessed repeated incidents of severe disregard for the marine environment. Numerous corals sustained damage from contact with hands and fins, and marine fauna were subjected to harassment and stress, all transpiring with the apparent indifference of the dive guide. I am sharing some illustrative scenes here to prompt reflection on these matters.
When engaging in underwater videography, the welfare of marine organisms must take absolute precedence over any image acquisition. If startled or disturbed, marine fauna may experience adverse consequences, ranging from simple stress – which can alter natural behaviors such as feeding or resting patterns – to developing wariness towards divers, or even being induced to abandon previously frequented habitats.
To ensure respectful interaction, it is crucial to avoid specific behaviors. For instance, concerning turtles, they must never be pursued if they attempt to withdraw. If an animal does not solicit interaction, its agency must be respected. Even if the animal appears tolerant, it is prudent to limit the duration of the interaction.
It is equally imperative to refrain from positioning the camera in extremely close proximity to the animal. This practice not only induces significant stress but also frequently results in suboptimal image quality, as the GoPro may fail to achieve proper focus at such short distances.
Physical contact with a turtle must be strictly avoided. Such contact can disrupt its protective cutaneous microbiome or simply cause alarm. It is essential to always ensure the animal has an unobstructed escape path and the ability to ascend to the surface for respiration. Obstructing this, even inadvertently, poses a significant risk. Finally, disturbing them during periods of rest or feeding solely for the purpose of image acquisition constitutes a lack of respect.
We are guests in their marine realm. No video or photograph, irrespective of its perceived spectacularity, justifies inflicting stress or potential harm upon a living organism.
The most meaningful footage is often procured through patience and profound respect. Ethical conduct ensures not only the acquisition of compelling imagery and cherished memories but, paramountly, a clear conscience.